I meant to publish this document some time ago, but I haven't had much time at all to post anything lately.

This document was a result of early project research into what DAL and BLL code generation tool that we should use. In sum the project was a CRM web application which was to be developed using the MSF Agile process. The requirements were loosely defined and likely to change. Before I had started at the company, a developer had already created a prototype site for the project using the NetTiers template for CodeSmith. Initially, I was extremely impressed with the generated code but as I started needing more customization, flexibility, and stability I decided to do a small comparison between NetTiers and LLBLGen to see which product best served our project.

This .doc file is the result of my findings:

Code Generation Product Comparison.doc

In the end we decided to go with LLBLGen. Looking back  a few months ago I definitely feel that this was the best decision that we could have made. Our company is so impressed that a couple of our other projects have purchased licenses and are under development as we speak.

Biggest reasons why we chose LLBLGen over NetTiers:

1. LLBLGen is much more flexible - We are capable of renaming entities, customizing property names, adding custom relationships, creating typed lists, etc.
2. LLBLGen will probably be supported much more strongly. Since NetTiers is an open source project we were concerned about building an important (costly) application on something which would bear little to no responsibility on any vendors.
3. NetTiers 2 was currently under development when we were considering the decision. As we modified the database and regenerated the project, we were running into both runtime and compiler errors.